Open Letters: On Life, Loss, Faith, and the Human Condition by Rabbi Lawrence A. Hoffman explores the challenges of navigating an uncertain world. In this excerpt, Rabbi Hoffman reflects on the personal loss that inspired him to write much of this collection of essays.
The death rate of humanity is stable across cultures: one death per person. No one gets out of this world alive. Who doesn’t know that?
But there are different kinds of knowing. The most common variety is how-to knowledge for getting around in the world: how to get dressed, entertain guests, call the plumber, pay a phone bill. A deeper kind of knowing is a meditative process we call discernment, the ability to judge a situation and arrive at a wise response. Different yet again is the way we know people as opposed to things—not surface knowing, the way we reach into memory and say of someone, “Yes, I met her once, I know who you mean,” but the way we know someone in all of their depth and complexity. For good reason, the Bible uses “knowing” as a euphemism for sexual relations, the most intimate knowing possible. But this type of knowing need not be sexual. Knowing in this deepest sense is what we say of those nearest and dearest to us, the people who really know us as we really know them.
Only when people like that die do we know the reality of human mortality. Until then, the fact that we all die is not much different from the fact that we all eat, run errands, go for walks, and plan birthday parties. Someone once said that death comes slowly and then all of a sudden: Here this moment, gone the next. We will never hold that person in our arms again.
I am a rabbi. One would think that rabbis might know about death without experiencing it firsthand in someone they love. Rabbis deal almost daily with death, don’t they? When someone dies, the rabbi is the specialist. We are usually the first person the bereaved family calls; we visit them to plan the funeral—sometimes earlier still, while the loved one’s body still lies lifeless awaiting the funeral home’s act of removal. We read centuries’ worth of textual advice on death and dying, grief and bereavement. We write about it, preach about it, lose track of the number of funerals at which we have officiated. How can rabbis not know the reality of death?
But even for rabbis, even for people who work at funeral homes (I suspect), even for the patient and downright saintly people who staff hospices—where dying is the whole point of being there—even they (I am pretty sure) do not really “know” death’s heavy hand until it strikes home with someone they love.
That, anyway, was my experience. Although for some, death comes with no warning, for others, we get to think about it through months or years of progressive illness. Even then, we do not know what death is until the moment it arrives. Nothing can fully prepare us for it.
Read more: ‘I Thought I Was Ready. I Wasn’t’: When a Rabbi Faces LossGayle and I met in 2010 and married in 2012, a second marriage for us both; people said it was an actual love story. Already in 2011, Gayle contracted a rare form of cancer and had it excised, but only with the probability that it would reappear, possibly within two years. We married anyway, hoping for the best. By 2016, the cancer had returned. Tiny laparoscopic surgeries put off the inevitable for quite some time. Then came chemotherapy, which worked for a while too. By the summer of 2021, Gayle was in home hospice care, and that August she died.
I thought I was ready for it. I wasn’t.
My earliest open letters, posted to Facebook and my blog, responded to COVID; all the while, Gayle’s cancer was being treated. In the months of mourning that followed her death, I began writing letters about death as I had finally, and painfully, come to know it: letters about life when life shuts down.
Rabbi Lawrence A. Hoffman, PhD, is the Barbara and Stephen Friedman Professor Emeritus of Liturgy, Worship, and Ritual at Hebrew Union College. His most recent book is Open Letters: On Life, Loss, Faith, and the Human Condition from CCAR Press.















