I never knew.
I never knew what this felt like.
I really never knew.
27 years as a rabbi, caring for others and yet,
I never knew.
After all those sermons about death and dying, about loss and living on,
I never knew.
Through the innumerable condolence calls, leading countless shiva minyanim, in fact
I never knew.
Over years of checking in on others,
In late night calls and texts
Just so they would know
They were not alone,
That we hadn’t forgotten, Still
I never knew.
Even after officiating at funeral after funeral after funeral,
Until the losses piled up so high that
They became part of the cycle of life
Yet each one representing a precious moment of memory, a unique life,
For some reason
I never knew.
Yes
He was old
And yes
He was ill
And yes
He was ready
And yet, still
While my loss is no greater, and
My pain is no sharper, while
My sadness is no deeper
Than those of countless others.
Still
This sadness, this sorrow
Is like no other
Because although I have counseled many others
Through the valley of the shadow of death,
Nonetheless
Nonetheless
Today this death is mine
And I am starting to realize:
The emptiness of loss
The sadness of what isn’t anymore
The foreverness of it all.
You see
My dad is dead.
And what is that like?
I think
I wish
I never knew.
—
Rabbi Paul Kipnes serves Congregation Or Ami in Calabasas, CA.
3 replies on “I Never Knew”
Thank you,Rabbi, for sharing this heartbreaking and heartwarming reflection. I am a psychologist and over the last 30+ years I, like you, shepherded countless clients through the grief of their losses. It was only when I lost my parents (within one year) that I also realized that “I never knew.” I learned (because I was taught during my training) to never say to a client, “I know how you feel.” Now I know why.
Paul, please call on me. Anne Brener
Thank you so much for this, Paul.